Who is the Body Dismemberer? *Spoilers?*

My vote is for pulling a "Batman, the long halloween;"
Multiple killers. One or two will be caught, but the others will remain unknown (but be hinted towards by the ending)

Serras-Kai wrote:My vote is for pulling a "Batman, the long halloween;"
Multiple killers. One or two will be caught, but the others will remain unknown (but be hinted towards by the ending)

I like this, makes for a much more interesting conclusion.

Serras-Kai wrote:My vote is for pulling a "Batman, the long halloween;"
Multiple killers. One or two will be caught, but the others will remain unknown (but be hinted towards by the ending)

Dude, that's awesome. Dunno why I never thought of that. Long Halloween was great by the way

you could teach a class about all the plausible stuff discussed in this thread

I vote Giygas.

Or Bowser.

I'm with the multiple killers theory.

Think about this for a second. Wario's description of the remains of the bodies: "All they found of the kids they ID'd were their internal organs. Tiny cuts." "The police...they come in...they find a Pokeball on the desk! And when they open it up...boom! Intestines, everywhere!" Then, Dedede's death is revealed, and all we see is a glob of giblets. Where's the rest of them???

We also see Olimar/End of Days cutting up a Pikmin into pieces, but he's too methodical... too slow. He wouldn't have had the time to slaughter Dedede between Luigi's visits. Not without help, anyway. Even if it's not Olimar, we're still left with why only pieces of victims are left behind - not entire bodies. Is it another cannibal, or are the rest of the body parts being transported somewhere without being seen?

It also makes me wonder what happened to Daisy, and why Luigi is taking this so personally. Was Daisy also a victim of this serial killer?

There are a few characters from the Smash Bros. series that we haven't seen yet. And any of them are currently suspects as well. It's all a matter of where they fit into this puzzle.

I don't like thinking it's Bowser, he's a Buddhist now according to Luigi. I think Link or Zelda could be it, with the police raid just happening after DeDeDe was supposed to meet with some mystery person, it could fit. Especially with Sheik. Another possibility is Meta Knight, but from what D3 said, he was just after Kirby, and at the asylum MK was all about Kirby, even when it was a crime scene he wouldn't leave and the police didn't seem to care that he was there.

So yeah haha, I think it's Zelda/Sheik, or possibly Meta Knight. Bowser I think, will be a good guy labeled as a bad guy, kinda like how D3 wanted better for the Kingdom, but was in the mob.

smashbro wrote:

Avalanche91 wrote:you could teach a class about all the plausible stuff discussed in this thread

QFT^

You could also spend half that time talking about The Meta Knight's plausible theories.

Thank you very much, kind sir.

The butler did it.


Discuss.

...Seriously though that multiple killer thing has got me thinking. The first conclusion we can rule out is "Everyone killed everyone else". By that I mean, we can rule out the possibility of Link, Ganon, Kirby, Olimar, Sheik/Zelda, Wario, etc. (mainly all the creepy folk) working consciously and purposefully together. There's a possibility one person was killed by a rogue agent, someone not trying to advance a grand scheme but just wanting personal satisfaction (Wario, oddly enough, could fall under this). We know for a fact that Link/Zelda and Ganon/Dedede/Bowser/Olimar are the two groups of "the bigger picture" players.

I shall formulate my opinion on a group effort theory and who may be responsible for the killings (side-lining the kidnapping for now).

When I first started watching the series I knew there were going to be some crazy twists. My first thought on who was the killer was Lucario, but when they showed him I was very disappointed. After I saw Lucario, I thought it could have been Rob, but again, I was disappointed by his appearance. So then I thought about it. As I thought I realized I forgot who was in brawl so I started up my game and began playing. As I played boss battle mode I thought about it being Tabuu or the Hands (mostly crazy hand cause the killer is essentially doing crazy things). Later speculation made me come to conclude that it probably wouldn't be because: this series shows more twisted versions of our beloved brawl characters, and while the main evil in the game is Tabuu/Hands, I don't think the writers will make it as easy as that. I mean, it's certainly plausible but it seems to easy.

Almost all the brawl characters have made their appearances in the show except for the Earthbound kids. I wouldn't be surprised if it is one of them. I mean they have the power no? Imagine a twisted version of kids that have power to shoot fire and such out of their hands. Though, in the back of my head, I think it's Kirby. Kirby may have been locked up for 5 years but you have to wonder; why would Peach even ask if there's no chance that Kirby can? I don't exactly have a solid theory on this but it also bugs me that Kirby knows so much from sitting in a cage for 5 years. Maybe he has some sort of informant or something? Maybe he's just be that good. But if he's that good to gain information so easily, what else can he do?

Jigglypuff also hasn't been shown in the series yet, and if you look at what they did to the Yoshi's and Kirby, what would they do to the other Pink puff in the game? Instead of singing and drawing on faces, she sings and, well...


I didn't think about this much but this is for if you guys want more to speculate about. They seem to have integrated the assist trophies into the story, and while most of them don't seem like cold hard killers, one of them pops into my head. That trophies happens to be Shadow. Shadow is a rather dark character already and Sonic and Shadow have what I like to call a "Vageta, Goku relationship" in the Sonic story. By that I mean that Shadow has a bad attitude and would do bad things if need be, but he ultimately does things for the greater good. If the sonic story wasn't so kid friendly, I'd easily be able to see Shadow as some evil villain; especially with Chaos Control.

So far that's all I can think of. I doubt any of my thoughts are valid but it's still fun to make a few points here and there. Anyway, I'll catch you guys later.

P.S. Great series, if I could, I would donate to you $100+ dollars but alas, I am but a 16 year old boy without money to spare. xD

Earthbound kids are playing in the alley at the end of episode four. Jigglypuff is with Pokemon Trainer when he is taking out the trash in episode six.

Oh yeah! I forgot that they showed the Earthbound kids. As for Jigglypuff, I was hoping that wasn't him in the trainer's hand but I guess it was. Oh well, that only leaves the Shadow theory.... And possibly Toon Link? (lol yeah right...)

to piont this out Young link has not shown up yet and neither has Toon link so Are they the killer is young link a Puppet Master

Didn't Zach say something about not wanting to include Toon Link in this at some point awhile back?

Relmitos wrote:Didn't Zach say something about not wanting to include Toon Link in this at some point awhile back?

Nope.
He just downright stated that Young Link is exactly the same character as Toon Link in this show.